Bookkeeper or accountant: what's the difference?
These aren't two versions of the same job, nor two price points for the same work. They are two distinct roles, and a healthy small business generally needs both — but not for the same number of hours, and not at the same rate.
The distinction in one sentence
The bookkeeper records what happens in your business, month after month. The chartered professional accountant attests, advises and prepares your tax filings, generally once a year.
Put another way: one keeps the raw material current, the other turns it into a finished product meant for the outside world — the tax authorities, the bank, a possible buyer.
Who does what, concretely
| Task | Who |
|---|---|
| Bank and card reconciliation | Bookkeeper |
| Entry of expenses and supplier invoices | Bookkeeper |
| Invoicing and receivables follow-up | Bookkeeper |
| GST and QST returns | Bookkeeper |
| Payroll, pay stubs and source deduction remittances | Bookkeeper |
| RL-1 slips, T4s and summaries | Bookkeeper |
| Year-end adjusting entries | CPA |
| Corporate income tax return | CPA |
| Financial statements with a review or audit engagement | CPA exclusively |
| Tax planning and corporate structure | CPA |
What the law reserves in Quebec
The title of chartered professional accountant and the abbreviation CPA are reserved to members of the Ordre des comptables professionnels agréés du Québec. Assurance engagements — the audit and review of financial statements — are reserved as well.
Bookkeeping, on the other hand, is not a reserved activity. Anyone may legally offer it. That's good news for your wallet and a reason to pay attention: quality varies enormously, and nothing requires a bookkeeper to have any training or experience.
A few markers to tell them apart:
- Ask how many years of experience, and in what kinds of businesses. A retail file looks nothing like a construction file.
- Ask how deadlines are tracked. GST/QST and source deduction remittances have fixed dates, and that's where the damage happens.
- Be wary of anyone promising "financial statements" without being a CPA. A bookkeeper produces management reports, which is useful and legitimate, but it isn't the same thing.
Why both, rather than one or the other
Handing bookkeeping to your CPA is expensive
A CPA firm commonly bills its time well above a bookkeeper's rate. Having them enter your supplier invoices means paying a specialist's rate for execution work. Many firms will happily do it — it's revenue — but few will recommend it to you unprompted.
Going without a CPA exposes you
Your corporation's income tax return, the tax elections attached to it, the decision to pay yourself a salary or a dividend: these carry lasting consequences. They deserve a professional whose trade this is, and whose professional liability is regulated.
The combination that works
A bookkeeper keeps your books current every month at a reasonable rate, then hands your CPA a complete, reconciled file at year-end. The CPA then only has to do what only they can do. Their hours go down, so their bill does too — and the saving often covers a good part of the bookkeeping cost.
It's also the arrangement most CPAs prefer. Receiving a box of unsorted invoices in February from a client who kept nothing for twelve months is nobody's idea of a good time, and it gets billed accordingly.
Isn't software enough?
Good accounting software imports your bank transactions automatically. That's real and it saves time. But importing isn't bookkeeping: someone still has to decide which account each transaction belongs to, match invoices to payments, spot what's missing, file returns on time and fix what doesn't balance.
Software miscodes silently. You only find out a year later, when the accountant opens the file — and that's when the catch-up begins.
I keep your books, your CPA does the rest
Eighteen years in the trade, rates posted from $99 a month, and a year-end file built so your accountant spends as few hours on it as possible. I am not a CPA and I don't claim to be — I do the monthly work, properly and on time.